Explaining self-esteem differences between Chinese and North Americans: Dialectical self (vs. self-consistency) or lack of positive self-regard

Young-Hoon Kim, Siqing Peng, Chi Yue Chiu

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

27 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Past studies showed that compared to North Americans, East Asians have lower self-esteem and their self-esteem scores do not predict self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions. These findings have been interpreted in terms of a lack of the need for positive self-regard in East Asian contexts. We posit that the East - West difference in self-esteem may arise from the popularity of the dialectical self (the idea that one can have both a positive and negative self) in East Asia and of the internally consistent self (the notion that having a positive self implies not having a negative one, and vice versa) in North America. Consistent with this idea, we found that the Chinese American difference in self-esteem level was driven primarily by Chinese participants' greater tendency to agree with negatively worded self-esteem items. Furthermore, because of the motivation to maintain consistent responses, North Americans' response pattern varied depending on whether the first item in the self-esteem measure was positively or negatively worded. Finally, contrary to the lack of positive self-regard explanation, for both Chinese and North Americans, agreement with positively worded self-esteem items predicted self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)113-128
Number of pages16
JournalSelf and Identity
Volume7
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2008 Apr 1

Fingerprint

Ego
Self Concept
Motivation
Asian Americans
Far East
North America

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Psychology(all)

Cite this

@article{db35706ceaca44729d22b3c9d3c53600,
title = "Explaining self-esteem differences between Chinese and North Americans: Dialectical self (vs. self-consistency) or lack of positive self-regard",
abstract = "Past studies showed that compared to North Americans, East Asians have lower self-esteem and their self-esteem scores do not predict self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions. These findings have been interpreted in terms of a lack of the need for positive self-regard in East Asian contexts. We posit that the East - West difference in self-esteem may arise from the popularity of the dialectical self (the idea that one can have both a positive and negative self) in East Asia and of the internally consistent self (the notion that having a positive self implies not having a negative one, and vice versa) in North America. Consistent with this idea, we found that the Chinese American difference in self-esteem level was driven primarily by Chinese participants' greater tendency to agree with negatively worded self-esteem items. Furthermore, because of the motivation to maintain consistent responses, North Americans' response pattern varied depending on whether the first item in the self-esteem measure was positively or negatively worded. Finally, contrary to the lack of positive self-regard explanation, for both Chinese and North Americans, agreement with positively worded self-esteem items predicted self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions.",
author = "Young-Hoon Kim and Siqing Peng and Chiu, {Chi Yue}",
year = "2008",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/15298860601063437",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "113--128",
journal = "Self and Identity",
issn = "1529-8868",
publisher = "Psychology Press Ltd",
number = "2",

}

Explaining self-esteem differences between Chinese and North Americans : Dialectical self (vs. self-consistency) or lack of positive self-regard. / Kim, Young-Hoon; Peng, Siqing; Chiu, Chi Yue.

In: Self and Identity, Vol. 7, No. 2, 01.04.2008, p. 113-128.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Explaining self-esteem differences between Chinese and North Americans

T2 - Dialectical self (vs. self-consistency) or lack of positive self-regard

AU - Kim, Young-Hoon

AU - Peng, Siqing

AU - Chiu, Chi Yue

PY - 2008/4/1

Y1 - 2008/4/1

N2 - Past studies showed that compared to North Americans, East Asians have lower self-esteem and their self-esteem scores do not predict self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions. These findings have been interpreted in terms of a lack of the need for positive self-regard in East Asian contexts. We posit that the East - West difference in self-esteem may arise from the popularity of the dialectical self (the idea that one can have both a positive and negative self) in East Asia and of the internally consistent self (the notion that having a positive self implies not having a negative one, and vice versa) in North America. Consistent with this idea, we found that the Chinese American difference in self-esteem level was driven primarily by Chinese participants' greater tendency to agree with negatively worded self-esteem items. Furthermore, because of the motivation to maintain consistent responses, North Americans' response pattern varied depending on whether the first item in the self-esteem measure was positively or negatively worded. Finally, contrary to the lack of positive self-regard explanation, for both Chinese and North Americans, agreement with positively worded self-esteem items predicted self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions.

AB - Past studies showed that compared to North Americans, East Asians have lower self-esteem and their self-esteem scores do not predict self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions. These findings have been interpreted in terms of a lack of the need for positive self-regard in East Asian contexts. We posit that the East - West difference in self-esteem may arise from the popularity of the dialectical self (the idea that one can have both a positive and negative self) in East Asia and of the internally consistent self (the notion that having a positive self implies not having a negative one, and vice versa) in North America. Consistent with this idea, we found that the Chinese American difference in self-esteem level was driven primarily by Chinese participants' greater tendency to agree with negatively worded self-esteem items. Furthermore, because of the motivation to maintain consistent responses, North Americans' response pattern varied depending on whether the first item in the self-esteem measure was positively or negatively worded. Finally, contrary to the lack of positive self-regard explanation, for both Chinese and North Americans, agreement with positively worded self-esteem items predicted self-esteem-related motivations and self-perceptions.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=40549104139&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=40549104139&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/15298860601063437

DO - 10.1080/15298860601063437

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:40549104139

VL - 7

SP - 113

EP - 128

JO - Self and Identity

JF - Self and Identity

SN - 1529-8868

IS - 2

ER -