Mediating love of humanity, love of country, and love of culture: A comparison of normative debates on global citizenship in South Korea and the United States

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article examines South Korean citizens' perspectives on global citizenship revealed in their public discourse in comparison with the outlooks that emerged in the landmark debate on patriotism and cosmopolitanism in the United States between moral philosopher Martha Nussbaum and her critics. Three key findings emerge: (1) in contrast with American skeptics of global citizenship who emphasize political loyalties and liberal patriotism, South Korean skeptics lean away from political allegiances in favor of traditional culture and identity; (2) themes such as reconciliation and poverty are discussed more prominently in the South Korean discourse than the American one; and (3) global citizenship debates in South Korea are bound up with anxiety about globalization and its accompanying issues and dynamics, such as Americanization, cultural shifts, and the country's economic competitiveness. South Korean global citizenship discourse enriches our broader understanding of patriotism and cosmopolitanism by illustrating how a rising democracy can shift gradually toward globally-minded political thinking while also focusing heavily on the protection and preservation of what is special and distinct within Korean culture.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)5-32
Number of pages28
JournalKorea Journal
Volume54
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 2014 Sep 1

Fingerprint

South Korea
love
patriotism
citizenship
cosmopolitanism
discourse
americanization
traditional culture
loyalty
reconciliation
competitiveness
critic
globalization
poverty
democracy
anxiety
citizen
Citizenship
economics
Patriotism

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Cultural Studies
  • History
  • Visual Arts and Performing Arts
  • Literature and Literary Theory

Cite this

@article{f48ba2b9076b40829d4b8dcaec6cb096,
title = "Mediating love of humanity, love of country, and love of culture: A comparison of normative debates on global citizenship in South Korea and the United States",
abstract = "This article examines South Korean citizens' perspectives on global citizenship revealed in their public discourse in comparison with the outlooks that emerged in the landmark debate on patriotism and cosmopolitanism in the United States between moral philosopher Martha Nussbaum and her critics. Three key findings emerge: (1) in contrast with American skeptics of global citizenship who emphasize political loyalties and liberal patriotism, South Korean skeptics lean away from political allegiances in favor of traditional culture and identity; (2) themes such as reconciliation and poverty are discussed more prominently in the South Korean discourse than the American one; and (3) global citizenship debates in South Korea are bound up with anxiety about globalization and its accompanying issues and dynamics, such as Americanization, cultural shifts, and the country's economic competitiveness. South Korean global citizenship discourse enriches our broader understanding of patriotism and cosmopolitanism by illustrating how a rising democracy can shift gradually toward globally-minded political thinking while also focusing heavily on the protection and preservation of what is special and distinct within Korean culture.",
author = "Hans Schattle",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "54",
pages = "5--32",
journal = "Korea Journal",
issn = "0023-3900",
publisher = "Korea Journal Korean National Commission for UNESCO",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Mediating love of humanity, love of country, and love of culture

T2 - A comparison of normative debates on global citizenship in South Korea and the United States

AU - Schattle, Hans

PY - 2014/9/1

Y1 - 2014/9/1

N2 - This article examines South Korean citizens' perspectives on global citizenship revealed in their public discourse in comparison with the outlooks that emerged in the landmark debate on patriotism and cosmopolitanism in the United States between moral philosopher Martha Nussbaum and her critics. Three key findings emerge: (1) in contrast with American skeptics of global citizenship who emphasize political loyalties and liberal patriotism, South Korean skeptics lean away from political allegiances in favor of traditional culture and identity; (2) themes such as reconciliation and poverty are discussed more prominently in the South Korean discourse than the American one; and (3) global citizenship debates in South Korea are bound up with anxiety about globalization and its accompanying issues and dynamics, such as Americanization, cultural shifts, and the country's economic competitiveness. South Korean global citizenship discourse enriches our broader understanding of patriotism and cosmopolitanism by illustrating how a rising democracy can shift gradually toward globally-minded political thinking while also focusing heavily on the protection and preservation of what is special and distinct within Korean culture.

AB - This article examines South Korean citizens' perspectives on global citizenship revealed in their public discourse in comparison with the outlooks that emerged in the landmark debate on patriotism and cosmopolitanism in the United States between moral philosopher Martha Nussbaum and her critics. Three key findings emerge: (1) in contrast with American skeptics of global citizenship who emphasize political loyalties and liberal patriotism, South Korean skeptics lean away from political allegiances in favor of traditional culture and identity; (2) themes such as reconciliation and poverty are discussed more prominently in the South Korean discourse than the American one; and (3) global citizenship debates in South Korea are bound up with anxiety about globalization and its accompanying issues and dynamics, such as Americanization, cultural shifts, and the country's economic competitiveness. South Korean global citizenship discourse enriches our broader understanding of patriotism and cosmopolitanism by illustrating how a rising democracy can shift gradually toward globally-minded political thinking while also focusing heavily on the protection and preservation of what is special and distinct within Korean culture.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84907887606&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84907887606&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84907887606

VL - 54

SP - 5

EP - 32

JO - Korea Journal

JF - Korea Journal

SN - 0023-3900

IS - 3

ER -