Utility-optimal medium access control: Reverse and forward engineering

Jang Won Lee, Mung Chiang, A. Robert Calderbank

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

34 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper analyzes and designs medium access control (MAC) protocols for wireless ad-hoc networks through the network utility maximization (NUM) framework. We first reverse-engineer the current exponential backoff (EB) type of MAC protocols such as the BEB (binary exponential backoff) in the IEEE 802.11 standard through a non-cooperative gametheoretic model. This MAC protocol is shown to be implicitly maximizing, using a stochastic subgradient, a selfish local utility at each link in the form of expected net reward for successful transmission. While the existence of a Nash equilibrium can be established, neither convergence nor social welfare optimality is guaranteed due to the inadequate feedback mechanism in the EB protocol. This motivates the forward-engineering part of the paper, where a network-wide utility maximization problem is formulated, using a collision and persistence probability model and aligning selfish utility with total social welfare. By adjusting the parameters in the utility objective functions of the NUM problem, we can also control the tradeoff between efficiency and fairness of radio resource allocation through a rigorous and systematic design. We develop two distributed algorithms to solve the MAC design NUM problem, which lead to random access protocols that have slightly more message passing overhead than the current EB protocol, but significant potential for efficiency and fairness improvement. We provide readily-verifiable sufficient conditions under which convergence of the proposed algorithms to a global optimality of network utility can be guaranteed, and through numerical examples illustrate the value of the NUM approach to the complexity-performance tradeoff in MAC design.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings - INFOCOM 2006
Subtitle of host publication25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2006 Dec 1
EventINFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications - Barcelona, Spain
Duration: 2006 Apr 232006 Apr 29

Publication series

NameProceedings - IEEE INFOCOM
ISSN (Print)0743-166X

Other

OtherINFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications
CountrySpain
CityBarcelona
Period06/4/2306/4/29

Fingerprint

Medium access control
Network protocols
Wireless ad hoc networks
Message passing
Parallel algorithms
Resource allocation
Feedback
Engineers

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Computer Science(all)
  • Electrical and Electronic Engineering

Cite this

Lee, J. W., Chiang, M., & Calderbank, A. R. (2006). Utility-optimal medium access control: Reverse and forward engineering. In Proceedings - INFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications [4146905] (Proceedings - IEEE INFOCOM). https://doi.org/10.1109/INFOCOM.2006.252
Lee, Jang Won ; Chiang, Mung ; Calderbank, A. Robert. / Utility-optimal medium access control : Reverse and forward engineering. Proceedings - INFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications. 2006. (Proceedings - IEEE INFOCOM).
@inproceedings{09a0735432c24745b3b58bd225039e3d,
title = "Utility-optimal medium access control: Reverse and forward engineering",
abstract = "This paper analyzes and designs medium access control (MAC) protocols for wireless ad-hoc networks through the network utility maximization (NUM) framework. We first reverse-engineer the current exponential backoff (EB) type of MAC protocols such as the BEB (binary exponential backoff) in the IEEE 802.11 standard through a non-cooperative gametheoretic model. This MAC protocol is shown to be implicitly maximizing, using a stochastic subgradient, a selfish local utility at each link in the form of expected net reward for successful transmission. While the existence of a Nash equilibrium can be established, neither convergence nor social welfare optimality is guaranteed due to the inadequate feedback mechanism in the EB protocol. This motivates the forward-engineering part of the paper, where a network-wide utility maximization problem is formulated, using a collision and persistence probability model and aligning selfish utility with total social welfare. By adjusting the parameters in the utility objective functions of the NUM problem, we can also control the tradeoff between efficiency and fairness of radio resource allocation through a rigorous and systematic design. We develop two distributed algorithms to solve the MAC design NUM problem, which lead to random access protocols that have slightly more message passing overhead than the current EB protocol, but significant potential for efficiency and fairness improvement. We provide readily-verifiable sufficient conditions under which convergence of the proposed algorithms to a global optimality of network utility can be guaranteed, and through numerical examples illustrate the value of the NUM approach to the complexity-performance tradeoff in MAC design.",
author = "Lee, {Jang Won} and Mung Chiang and Calderbank, {A. Robert}",
year = "2006",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1109/INFOCOM.2006.252",
language = "English",
isbn = "1424402212",
series = "Proceedings - IEEE INFOCOM",
booktitle = "Proceedings - INFOCOM 2006",

}

Lee, JW, Chiang, M & Calderbank, AR 2006, Utility-optimal medium access control: Reverse and forward engineering. in Proceedings - INFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications., 4146905, Proceedings - IEEE INFOCOM, INFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications, Barcelona, Spain, 06/4/23. https://doi.org/10.1109/INFOCOM.2006.252

Utility-optimal medium access control : Reverse and forward engineering. / Lee, Jang Won; Chiang, Mung; Calderbank, A. Robert.

Proceedings - INFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications. 2006. 4146905 (Proceedings - IEEE INFOCOM).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Utility-optimal medium access control

T2 - Reverse and forward engineering

AU - Lee, Jang Won

AU - Chiang, Mung

AU - Calderbank, A. Robert

PY - 2006/12/1

Y1 - 2006/12/1

N2 - This paper analyzes and designs medium access control (MAC) protocols for wireless ad-hoc networks through the network utility maximization (NUM) framework. We first reverse-engineer the current exponential backoff (EB) type of MAC protocols such as the BEB (binary exponential backoff) in the IEEE 802.11 standard through a non-cooperative gametheoretic model. This MAC protocol is shown to be implicitly maximizing, using a stochastic subgradient, a selfish local utility at each link in the form of expected net reward for successful transmission. While the existence of a Nash equilibrium can be established, neither convergence nor social welfare optimality is guaranteed due to the inadequate feedback mechanism in the EB protocol. This motivates the forward-engineering part of the paper, where a network-wide utility maximization problem is formulated, using a collision and persistence probability model and aligning selfish utility with total social welfare. By adjusting the parameters in the utility objective functions of the NUM problem, we can also control the tradeoff between efficiency and fairness of radio resource allocation through a rigorous and systematic design. We develop two distributed algorithms to solve the MAC design NUM problem, which lead to random access protocols that have slightly more message passing overhead than the current EB protocol, but significant potential for efficiency and fairness improvement. We provide readily-verifiable sufficient conditions under which convergence of the proposed algorithms to a global optimality of network utility can be guaranteed, and through numerical examples illustrate the value of the NUM approach to the complexity-performance tradeoff in MAC design.

AB - This paper analyzes and designs medium access control (MAC) protocols for wireless ad-hoc networks through the network utility maximization (NUM) framework. We first reverse-engineer the current exponential backoff (EB) type of MAC protocols such as the BEB (binary exponential backoff) in the IEEE 802.11 standard through a non-cooperative gametheoretic model. This MAC protocol is shown to be implicitly maximizing, using a stochastic subgradient, a selfish local utility at each link in the form of expected net reward for successful transmission. While the existence of a Nash equilibrium can be established, neither convergence nor social welfare optimality is guaranteed due to the inadequate feedback mechanism in the EB protocol. This motivates the forward-engineering part of the paper, where a network-wide utility maximization problem is formulated, using a collision and persistence probability model and aligning selfish utility with total social welfare. By adjusting the parameters in the utility objective functions of the NUM problem, we can also control the tradeoff between efficiency and fairness of radio resource allocation through a rigorous and systematic design. We develop two distributed algorithms to solve the MAC design NUM problem, which lead to random access protocols that have slightly more message passing overhead than the current EB protocol, but significant potential for efficiency and fairness improvement. We provide readily-verifiable sufficient conditions under which convergence of the proposed algorithms to a global optimality of network utility can be guaranteed, and through numerical examples illustrate the value of the NUM approach to the complexity-performance tradeoff in MAC design.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33646422015&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33646422015&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1109/INFOCOM.2006.252

DO - 10.1109/INFOCOM.2006.252

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:33646422015

SN - 1424402212

SN - 9781424402212

T3 - Proceedings - IEEE INFOCOM

BT - Proceedings - INFOCOM 2006

ER -

Lee JW, Chiang M, Calderbank AR. Utility-optimal medium access control: Reverse and forward engineering. In Proceedings - INFOCOM 2006: 25th IEEE International Conference on Computer Communications. 2006. 4146905. (Proceedings - IEEE INFOCOM). https://doi.org/10.1109/INFOCOM.2006.252